Monday, March 21, 2005

Sony Pictures are a bunch of f@#@ heads

The story goes: I placed the Kungfu Hustle DVD online for sale at ebay. Then it was pulled by ebay saying that they were contacted by Sony Pictures that I am infringing on their copyright policies. I contacted Sony and they gave me a canned answer. I responded angrily demanding an explanation for double standards and they didn't respond. Once again, I posted the item on ebay after 1 week and they pulled it again. Here are the email exchanges, starting from the earliest.

---------------------------------------
Dear Yee-Wei Chai (ywchai@mac.com),

**PLEASE READ THIS IMPORTANT EMAIL REGARDING YOUR LISTING(S)**

We would like to let you know that we removed your listing:
6379569310 Kung Fu Hustle DVD Collector's Gift Set
because the intellectual property rights owner notified us, under penalty of perjury, that your listing or the item itself infringes their copyright, trademark, or other rights.

We have credited any associated fees to your account. We have also notified the bidders that the listing(s) was removed, and that they are not obligated to complete the transaction.

If you relist this or any other similar items on eBay, your account likely will be suspended.

If you believe your listing was ended in error, or have questions regarding the removal of this listing, please contact the intellectual property rights owner directly at:

Sony Pictures Entertainment
piracy@spe.sony.com

eBay is available to answer questions, but since it is the rights owner that requested the removal of your listing(s), we encourage you to contact them first.

For more information on eBay's cooperation with rights owners through the VeRO Program, and a list of rights owners that have created About Me pages, please visit:

http://pages.ebay.com/help/confidence/vero-removed-listing.html
http://pages.ebay.com/help/community/vero-aboutme.html

Thank you for your cooperation.

Regards,

Customer Support (Trust and Safety Department)
eBay Inc
-----------------------------

And so I responded:

Yee-wei Chai

03/03/2005 04:55 PM
To:        piracy@spe.sony.com
cc:        
Subject:        RE: ebay listing ended

Hello,

I recently had an ebay listing removed  by the ebay Vero system and I
wasn't given a proper reason why it had infringed on any interllectual
ppty. Your email was listed for contact so I want to know what was the
reason for so?  The DVD is original, everything was new and why shld I
be penalised for listing something that is not pirated?? My ebay record
has been perfect and with such removal you have seriously impacted my
image on ebay.

The DVD in question was 6373700920 Kung Fu Hustle Limited Edition
Collector's Gift Set DVD. It was an official release and purchased from
HK. What is the problem here?? Could you kindly explain??

Yee-wei Chai
ebay id yeeweichai
-----------------------------------------------------

Then I got a response from Sony Pictures:

From: Piracy@spe.sony.com
Subject: RE: ebay listing ended
Date: 11 Mar 2005 AM 02:28:58
To: ywchai@mac.com

Sony Pictures Classics Inc. ("SPC") holds the exclusive right to distribute the motion picture, "Kung Fu Hustle" worldwide in all formats. As such, SPC is the only entity authorized to distribute this motion picture for sale in any format worldwide. SPC has not yet released this motion picture in the United States theatrically or in home entertainment. Any other company or individual that sells this motion picture or offers this motion picture for sale in the United States infringes SPC's exclusive distribution rights in the United States

------------------------------------------------------------

Then I replied again:

From: Yee-Wei Chai
Date: 11 Mar 2005 AM 11:17:02
To: Piracy@spe.sony.com
Cc: send-news-suggestions@cnet.com, harry@aintitcool.com, answerman@gmail.com
Subject: Re: ebay listing ended

Dear Sony Pictures,

This doesn't makes sense. Plenty of people sells Code 1 DVDs to the rest of the world even though they are not released (or never released) and no one is going after these individuals. I live in a region Code 3 country (Singapore), but Code 1 discs are available everywhere. Does it make all these retailers illegal? Furthermore, I see other ebay selllers still listing this item, as well as other Asia DVDs/CDs sites like "Yesasia.com" selling the same item as well worldwide including US. What gives them more right to do so than myself? Are you coming after me because I am easier to scare/pick on? Why don't you pick on someone your own size.

I am re-selling my DVD to someone else in other parts of the world, not just US. Piracy is a term used for thieves and I am certainly not pleased for being branded as such when what I am doing is exactly what everyone else on ebay is doing - selling different region DVDs to places which are of not the same region indicated.

This region coding technology is a chore and a hassle in an extremely interconnected world of today. Everyone is more international than ever before thanks to the proliferation of understanding between cultures and countries. To set up this region coding to prevent reduced profits due to your inefficient distribution penalizes those individuals who are well travelled and speak multiple languages. I am a fan of japanese movies, HK movies, US movies, and as a result of your region coding, it has extremely inconvenienced me in my pursuit of exploring the different myriad of movies out there. Would the only legal solution for people like me (which there are plenty) be to purchase a DVD player from each different region so as to enjoy DVDs from different countries?

I am copying this email message to Cnet, ainitcool.com, as well as Roger Ebert in hopes that this ridiculous issue of region coding which was introduced to the world by the selfish media giants, may be brought to more attention and generate discussion.

I love movies, and I love music. I have always sought to support the movie and music industry by purchasing originals although I live in a region which sees the proliferation of pirated medias. I have even sought to study film in college and is now in the process of shooting my own short film. But in recent years, the media giants have been seeking many ways to prevent piracy and their methods have been taking its toll on legal supporters like myself. In light of all the "rules and regulations" set by these bodies, it is giving the "law-abiding" end-users less reason to support them. There's always the big media firms complaining about the how much profits they are losing through piracy and how they have to implement DRM to fight the pirates. But who is speaking up for the legitimate users like us who are getting their rights shreds to bits over the years?

Yee-Wei Chai
Singapore
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And after more than 1 week, I still haven't heard back from Sony. So thus I relisted the item, seeing that tons of people are still selling Kung Fu Hustle on ebay, obviously ebay didn't go after them. But 1 day after listing it, it got removed again. This time I am mighty pissed as expected.

Here's my latest response back to Sony again:

From: Yee-Wei Chai
Date: 22 Mar 2005 AM 10:47:30
To: whyended@ebay.com
Cc: piracy@spe.sony.com
Subject: Re: VeRO NOTICE: eBay Listing(s) Removed - VeRO Program

Dear Ebay and Sony,

I do not understand why is my item being removed/unallowed to sell on ebay when a search of kung fu hustle results in so many other listing that are legit and even allowed to complete auction? This is the 2nd time this has happened. I have contacted Sony regarding my item and they gave a unreasonable and unsatisfactory answer. I responded but they never answered back for more than a week. The double standards by Sony and ebay (vero) is unacceptable.

I seriously demand an explanation why am I not allowed to sell this item when others could? What makes my act one of piracy versus the rest of the ebayers?? Why am I targeted?

The last response from Sony is as follows:
Sony Pictures Classics Inc. ("SPC") holds the exclusive right to distribute the motion picture, "Kung Fu Hustle" worldwide in all formats. As such, SPC is the only entity authorized to distribute this motion picture for sale in any format worldwide. SPC has not yet released this motion picture in the United States theatrically or in home entertainment. Any other company or individual that sells this motion picture or offers this motion picture for sale in the United States infringes SPC's exclusive distribution rights in the United States.

Then please answer my questions:
1) Why are other ebayers allowed to sell the same item I am selling?
2) If "SPC is the only entity to distribute the picture in any format worldwide", why are retailers in Hong Kong and Singapore allowed to sell them everywhere? These include legitimate companies like HMV and Tower Records
3) If "Any other company or individual that sells this motion picture or offers this motion picture for sale in the United States infringes SPC's exclusive distribution rights in the United States.", why are US online retailers like Yesasia.com allowed to do so, and even continue to do so after taking down my listing? Why the double standards?

I expect a response from both ebay and sony picture classics regarding this issue, and addressing all the points I have listed above.

Regards,
Yee-Wei

----------------------------------------

I will update the site with my latest saga on this issue so check back often to see what these shitheads at Sony and ebay has got to say.

2 Comments:

Blogger Yuhui said...

If I may be devil's advocate for a while...

Firstly, it seems that there are several versions of the "Kung Fu Hustle" DVD, among which are the Collector's Gift Set and the "regular" DVD with no extras (like what you'd get at video rental stores).

What you're selling -- and what SPC claims to have exclusive distributorship -- is the Collector's Gift Set. Unless SPC claims otherwise (which I don't note reading anywhere), it DOES NOT have exclusive distributorship of the other DVD versions (regardless of region coding), so other people can sell it.

If this is true, then it looks like you can legally sell the "regular" DVD version, but NOT the Collector's Gift Set. And based on a cursory search on eBay, those are the ONLY versions of "Kung Fu Hustle" that I found on sale there.

And then there's the distributor-retail chain, i.e. SPC doesn't sell directly to the public but, as the exclusive distributor, provides its stock to its network of licensed retailers to sell to the public.

Some of these retailers could be selling on eBay, and because they are licensed by SPC, so they can sell their "Kung Fu Hustle" DVDs, including the Collector's Gift Set, without being accused of piracy or the like.

So there are two things you need to ask:
1. Which version of DVD, i.e. Collector's Gift Set or something else, can an end user sell in a public space/forum without requiring special permission and without fear of criminialization?
2. Are the eBay sellers part of of SPC's retail network (and are therefore allowed to sell SPC's products, including the "Kung Fu Hustle" DVD Collector's Gift Set, in a public space/forum)?

Note that these have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with region coding. In fact, if you argue from that point of view, you're walking into a death trap, because then you appear as a pirate, whether you intend to or not. So my advice: STAY AWAY from the region coding argument.

What I would ask, if I were in your shoes, is whether I can sell a USED copy of the Collector's Gift Set. I should be able to do so under copyright law and because I have proven myself to be the first buyer of that particular item, so SPC has theoretically earned its money from me already.

But if you insist on selling it as a BRAND NEW item, then I think you need to address the two questions above.

Remember: I'm just being devil's advocate. Personally, I think you should be able to sell it under any circumstances (new or old, Collector's Gift Set or otherwise, Region 1 or Region 3 or some other region, etc.) because it's YOUR item, i.e. you bought it with your own money (you did, right?).

6:03 PM  
Blogger Yee-wei Chai said...

Yup i did buy it with my own money. My listing on ebay states "I have purchased this from Hong Kong". I never claimed it to be brand new, but it is definitely sealed (not specifically stated too). And actually, if you search under "completed" ebay items, several sellers have completed their sale of this "deluxe" edition already. And in case you didn't know, the deluxe box set contain the exact same regular DVD as the ones being sold online, just with a different packaging bundled with extras. Even the DVD case in the deluxe set is that one of the regular one. But we shouldn't be entering into the specifics because their answer didn't enter into these specifics of different versions. Their simple answer was directed at the distribution of the movie - irregardless of the versions.

11:47 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home